Korey Williams fired a 4-over par 39 at Seneca Hills, leading New Riegel to a 168-247 over Bettsville.
Andrew Hohman followed Williams with a 41, while Brady Hall shot a 43.
Bettsville, which used four players, was led by Ryan Hager shooting 49.
Columbian bumps Willard
WILLARD - Bryce Creamer shot a 2-over-par 38, two strokes better than Columbian teammate Jack Burkes, as the Tornadoes upended Willard, 175-182, for their first league win.
Hunter Wiers shot a 42 to lead the Flashes.
Columbian 175, Willard 182
at Willard Golf Club
Columbian: Bryce Creamer 38; Jack Burkes 40; T.J. Wickham 49; Mason McCool 52; Clayton Neal 53; Eline Widman 48.
Willard: Hunter Wiers 42; Korey Mahl DQ; Matt Cok 44; Daren Mull 50; Jake Tanner 47; Logan Schaub 49.
New Riegel 168, Bettsville 247
at Seneca Hills
New Riegel: Andrew Hohman 41; Brady Hall 43; Korey Williams 39; Brandyn Reinhart 45; Aaron Reinhart 53; Jared Coleman 56.
Bettsville: Ryan Hager 49; Tommy Kipps 54; Logan Robinson 72; Kyle Hager 72.