Counter culture: History and nostalgia also occupy shelves at Beeker’s General Store

PHOTO BY VICKI JOHNSON Todd Sheets, owner of Beeker’s General Store in Pemberville, assists local customer Roberta Gacsal with a purchase.

The old wooden floorboards creak when a customer steps inside the doors of Beeker’s General Store in Pemberville.

History and nostalgia are evident from the wooden counters, gas lampshades and tin ceiling.

“It is one of Ohio’s oldest general stores. You can sit on the same stools they did in 1917,” said owner Todd Sheets, who purchased the store and the 141-year-old building 23 years ago. “It features a lot of the original fixtures.”

A picture hanging on an old spool cabinet shows a snapshot of the business as it looked in 1917.

“So, actually, that picture is 100 years old,” he said.

The store’s candy counter.

The photo shows many of the historical products the store sold, such as umbrellas in the umbrella case.

“It shows the ribbon case, which is very unique,” he said.

Today’s wooden counters still stretch down both sides of the store, filled with products — vintage and modern.

The top shelf is reserved for memorabilia that isn’t for sale, and some of it has been there for a long time.

“We’re a working general store and a museum, all in one,” he said.

Historical memorabilia lines shelving along the store’s walls

“Beeker’s was part of the Brick Block, the first brick business buildings in Pemberville, constructed in 1876,” Sheets said. “The store became Beeker’s in 1924 when Fred Beeker acquired the building and the business.”

According to records, Sheets said the building was built by Froney & Bruning, followed by the Zindler Brothers before partners Beeker and Witker bought it.

“Miss Mildred Beeker continued in her father’s footsteps, maintaining the tradition until age 89,” Sheets said.

He said her father bought the business with a partner, and then later owned it himself.

Upon his death, Sheets said, Mildred and her mother continued to operate the store. And Mildred, an only child who never married, continued until age 89.

A case displays spools of ribbon in the store

While Mildred was proprietor, Sheets worked for her from age 12 through his teen years.

A florist by trade, he said he worked for five years at a large florist in the Toledo area before purchasing Beeker’s from Mildred in 1994.

“We didn’t change the name,” he said. “We didn’t buy it for our name recognition. We bought it to continue the tradition.”

Serving Pemberville for four generations, Beeker’s originally served the farm community surrounding the town, and much of the store’s merchandise is reminiscent of the items customers have purchased at the store for more than 100 years.

He remembers stories Miss Beeker told about the days when Pemberville had many businesses and multiple grocery stores.

Taffy is seen in containers.

“That was the big thing on Saturday night, to come into town,” he said. “They came for gossip and groceries, and in that order.

“Farmers would have brought their eggs and fresh produce and bartered for flour and dry goods, whatever they might have a need for — flour, salt, sugar,” he said.

Although not much bartering takes place today, the store continues to offer similar merchandise.

“We have a lot of handcrafted items, many of which are one of a kind,” he said. “We have many Amish food products — jams, jellies, pickles, relishes.”

The store features Country Grains Bread Co. breads once a month, and a local baker provides sweet baked goods every Friday.

Memorabilia in the store

In addition to food, the store offers soaps and lotions, fabric, children’s books and toys – and that only scratches the surface.

“There’s a lot of gift items that would have a vintage feeling to them, or be reminiscent of days gone by,” Sheets said. “We do a lot with the different seasons and holidays. Vintage and nostalgia Christmas and Easter. We have Halloween coming up.”

In addition to the top shelf of museum items, Sheets said there often are “vintage finds” offered for sale.

“We have a great loyal base of local people from surrounding communities,” Sheets said.

And the store has frequent visitors from towns such as Perrysburg, Fremont, Sylvania and Findlay, and also from a bit further such as Cleveland and Michigan.

“At holiday time and Pemberville Fair time, we have lots of families coming home,” he said. “It’s a tradition that they come to the store.”

He said people take family photos at Beeker’s.

Sheets is asking his customers or any people from the greater Toledo area to help with a holiday display this year.

“We’re doing something kind of unique this fall and holiday season,” he said. The store is to host a display called “Holy Toledo, it’s Tiedtke’s.”

Sheets said visitors from the Toledo area often comment on how much Beeker’s reminds them of the old Tiedtke’s store, which was a similar general store at Summit and Adams streets in downtown Toledo. The store closed in 1973 and the original building was destroyed by fire two years later.

“That was a Toledo landmark for many years,” he said.

Between Sept. 15 and Oct. 15, Sheets invites anyone who owns Tiedtke’s memorabilia to drop it off at Beeker’s.

“It will be on display from the end of October through the new year,” he said. “We’re looking for things that say Tiedtke’s, memories, pictures.”

While they’re in town, Sheets invites visitors to take a look at the entire town of Pemberville.

People can choose to visit Beeker’s, an antique store and other businesses for a day of nostalgic shopping and stop in between for lunch, he said.

Two good opportunities to visit would be two special events coming up, he said.

Oct. 28 is the Pemberville Harvest Gathering Arts Fair and Craft Show, sponsored by Pemberville Historical Society.

“That’s a fun day for us,” he said. “We host our fall open house that day.”

The day features great food, he said, including traditional snipple bean soup, a traditional German soup.

The Christmas Open House takes place the Saturday and Sunday after Thanksgiving, he said.

“We are open on Friday, but Pemberville rolls out the red carpet on Saturday and Sunday,” he said. “It ends Sunday evening with a lighted parade, and it gets bigger and brighter every year.”

The weekend features carriage rides, tours of historical society sites, a Festival of Trees at the opera house and a bake sale.

“It’s all kinds of fun, an old-fashioned Christmas,” he said.

All year round, Beeker’s is open 9 a.m.-5:30 p.m. Monday through Saturday and noon-4 p.m. Sunday.

“Come see us because it’s a step back in time,” Sheets said. “It’s a bit of history.”

If you go …

Beeker’s address is 226 E. Front St. (SR 105), Pemberville.

To contact the store, call (419) 287 -3274 or email

Find the store on Facebook at

Sheets rings up Gacsal’s purchase.